Renault Scenic 3
Weaknesses, engine ratings and buying advice
The Scenic III and Grand Scenic III (2009–2016) is a clever compact MPV that puts space before handling — the Grand Scenic with seven seats the practical family car. Its dented reputation stems mainly from the early years; from 2011 quality improved noticeably.
The clear favourite is the R9M (1.6 dCi 130, from 2011): a timing chain, a cultured note, a real ~6 l/100 km and good for well over 150,000 km. In a long-term test the Grand Scenic with this diesel posted the best Renault result of its era. The M9R (2.0 dCi) hauls the heavy seven-seater with ease but drinks more. The K9K (1.5 dCi) is frugal and proven — here the timing belt with water pump matters, due every 120,000 km or so.
Beware the H4J (1.4 TCe): besides high consumption, cracked engine blocks from certain casting batches are known — coolant loss, running on three cylinders, ultimately a replacement engine around $4,500. The H5F (1.2 TCe) with chain wear and oil use is no recommendation either, and the F9Q (1.9 dCi) was dropped for a reason.
Test-drive checklist: Release and apply the electronic parking brake several times and park on a slope — if it plays up the control unit is due and must be coded to the VIN with CLIP, used parts won't do. Check under the driver's seat and in the boot corners for water (blocked drains, leaking third brake light). On the TCe listen for a cold-start rattle, on the diesel demand belt proof.
2026 market: Entry from around $2,500 (high mileage), average $5,500–6,000, well-kept late years 2014–2016 up to $8,000–11,000. The Grand Scenic sits only marginally above the regular Scenic.
Insider pick: 1.6 dCi (R9M) from 2011 — the smooth chain diesel is the engine with the most long-term potential. But if you mostly drive short trips, don't buy a diesel Scenic at all (DPF) and avoid the EDC gearbox — for the city profile the manual is mandatory.
160 PS
Scenic · Diesel
Top Diesel
Decent101–132 PS
1.2L TCe Benzin
8 weaknesses
Stay Away!Generations
Engine Overview
The Renault Scenic 3 is available with 8 engine variants — from 61 to 200 hp.
Renault's most-produced diesel with over 20 years of production history — with exemplary maintenance (oil every 10,000 km, fuel filter every 8,000–10,000 km) over 300,000 km is achievable. Biggest weakness: connecting rod bearings spin from around 100,000–150,000 km, especially with extended oil change intervals. Common-rail injectors (Delphi) and EGR valve are further service items.
- !! Connecting Rod Bearing Wear from 150,000 km
The K9K connecting rod bearings are design-sensitive. With overly long oil change intervals or incorrect oil the bearing shells spin from around 100,000–150,000 km, resulting in total engine failure.
Symptoms: Knocking engine noise, oil pressure warning light, sudden engine stop - !! High-Pressure Pump (Delphi) Failure from 90,000 km
The Delphi high-pressure pump shows weaknesses from around 80,000 km. Metal wear from the pump contaminates the fuel circuit and damages the injectors and common rail — with consequential damage included.
Symptoms: Starting difficulties, sudden engine stall, 'injection fault' message - !! Timing belt failure — engine destruction from 120,000 km
The 1.5 dCi is an interference belt engine. With an overdue change interval or faulty fitting the belt snaps, valves and pistons collide — total loss. Early failures well before the scheduled interval are documented.
Symptoms: Sudden engine stall without warning, refusal to start, metallic noises shortly before failure
+ 5 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
Modern 1.6-litre common-rail diesel with timing chain and up to 160 hp in the bi-turbo version — constructively complex and repair-intensive when damaged. Timing chain frequently elongates from 140,000–150,000 km; piezo injectors, EGR valve and DPF are known trouble sources. Only buy with complete service history and after engine inspection.
- !! Timing Chain Stretch from 145,000 km
The R9M timing chain sometimes stretches from as early as 140,000–150,000 km, despite a stated 250,000 km service life. Chain failure leads to valve contact and total engine damage — a costly risk.
Symptoms: Rattling noise on cold start, engine warning light, harsh engine noise - !! Connecting Rod Failure (Condensation Water) from 80,000 km
The R9M 452 repeatedly suffers connecting rod failures attributed to condensation water ingested from the intercooler. Short oil change intervals and frequent short trips increase the risk.
Symptoms: Loud knock from the engine, sudden engine stop, oil pressure loss - !! EGR Cooler Crack / Coolant Loss from 100,000 km
The EGR cooler on the R9M is prone to cracking, allowing coolant to enter the intake system. The result is not only power loss but in extreme cases engine damage from water ingestion.
Symptoms: Coolant loss without visible cause, white smoke, exhaust smell in the cabin
+ 5 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
A robust common-rail diesel from the early dCi generation — the Bosch injection system is generally reliable. Known weak points are turbocharger issues, connecting-rod bearing damage and an oil-pump pickup screen that wears with mileage and, if neglected, leads to bearing failure. An oil change every 10,000 km is therefore mandatory. The injectors are sensitive to poor fuel quality. Change the timing belt every 90,000 to 120,000 km; as an interference engine the consequences of a snap are severe.
- !! Turbocharger Failure from 140,000 km
The turbocharger on the F9Q is a known weak spot. Shaft play, oil supply problems and heat damage cause power loss and limp mode, typically from 120,000–160,000 km.
Symptoms: Whistling from turbo, power loss, blue/white smoke clouds, limp mode - !! Injector Failure from 120,000 km
The common-rail injectors on the F9Q are prone to contamination and mechanical wear. Loose injectors or faulty injection leads to misfires and the fault code 'injection defective'.
Symptoms: Engine stumbling, misfires, difficult cold start, 'injection defective' message - !! EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits from 100,000 km
The EGR valve and intercooler on the F9Q are prone to heavy sooting. A burst intercooler manifests as power loss and heavy smoke — a well-known problem on early Laguna II models.
Symptoms: Heavy smoke, significant power loss, rough engine running
+ 2 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
2.0-litre diesel developed jointly with Nissan with timing chain and good fundamental long-term robustness — with correct maintenance well over 300,000 km is possible. Weak point is the turbocharger boost pressure control on early examples (2005–2006). Timing chain can start to rattle from 200,000 km; oil quality is critical.
- !! Injector Removal Causes Cylinder Head Damage from 150,000 km
On the M9R the valve cover also serves as the camshaft bearing — both parts are machined together. A damaged valve cover during injector removal will inevitably destroy the cylinder head as well.
Symptoms: Damage occurs during improper repair; no prior warning - !! Coolant Loss / Seal Damage from 180,000 km
Faulty seals or cracks in the M9R engine block can lead to coolant loss. Overheating threatens if the problem is not detected early — especially at higher mileages.
Symptoms: Falling coolant level, overheating warning, white smoke from exhaust - !! Timing chain stretch from 200,000 km
The 2.0 dCi uses a timing chain that stretches at high mileage and wears the sprockets. If the chain jumps, valve damage follows. Replacement usually requires removing the engine and is correspondingly costly.
Symptoms: Rattle on cold start from the front timing chain area that fades once warm
+ 5 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
Widely used 1.2 TCe four-cylinder with a structural problem: the oil pump intermittently under-supplies the timing chain tensioner, leading to chain rattle, camshaft adjuster wear and increased oil consumption. Consumption over 1 l/1,000 km is not uncommon. Always check oil consumption before purchase and listen for chain noise.
- !! Timing Chain Stretches Prematurely from 60,000 km
The most well-known H5F problem: the timing chain stretches significantly — especially with short-trip use or missed oil changes — potentially causing rattling and engine damage from 70,000–100,000 km. Oil dilution from short trips accelerates wear.
Symptoms: Rattling on cold start, clattering on load changes, camshaft control fault code, engine damage - !! High Oil Consumption from 40,000 km
The H5F consumes increasing amounts of oil over its service life, often through worn piston rings or leaking valve stem seals. Values of 0.5–1.5 litres per 1,000 km are known from forum reports.
Symptoms: Oil level visibly drops between changes, blue smoke on acceleration - !! Turbocharger Failure from 100,000 km
The H5F turbocharger suffers from oil supply problems, worsened by oil dilution from short trips and extended change intervals. Turbo damage is expensive.
Symptoms: Whistling from the turbo, blue smoke, power loss, no boost build-up
+ 5 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
A turbocharged four-cylinder with a pronounced timing-chain weakness: chain stretch can cause engine damage as early as 75,000 to 150,000 km, up to connecting-rod bearing failure, and replacement usually means removing the engine. The aluminium head warps when overheated, with documented head-gasket failures mixing oil and coolant. Oil consumption via the turbo bearings and ignition coil failures add to it. A pre-purchase inspection and complete service history are mandatory here.
- !! Chain Tensioner: Cold-Start Rattle and Stretch from 120,000 km
In the H4J700 the timing chain stretches from around 130,000 km, noticeable as rattling on cold start. The hydraulic chain tensioner needs more travel once the chain has stretched — repair costs around €3,000.
Symptoms: Knocking/rattling noise from the timing chain area on cold start, lasting 3–4 minutes and subsiding after warm-up. - !! Cylinder Head Crack: Coolant Loss from 100,000 km
Known issue on the H4J: cracks in the cylinder head allow coolant to enter the combustion chambers. Identifiable by a falling coolant level without any visible external leak. Typical after 80,000–120,000 km.
Symptoms: Coolant level drops regularly without visible leak; white smoke from exhaust; mayonnaise deposits on oil filler cap. - !! Wastegate Wear on the Small Turbo from 100,000 km
The H4J 1.0 TCe 90 in the Clio V shows similar wastegate mechanism wear to the H4B. Still not well-documented as a young engine, but confirmed from forum experience.
Symptoms: Power loss, whistling noises, no boost pressure build-up
+ 3 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The K4M in the Twingo RS — 1.6 litres, 16 valves, 133 hp — is a naturally aspirated engine with an honest character: it needs revs, but rewards every blip above 5,000 rpm with a rev-happy sound that turbocharged cars cannot reproduce. In the 980 kg Twingo RS it feels stronger than the numbers suggest. Timing belt every 120,000 km or 6 years — water pump always at the same time. Camshaft adjuster wears with excessive oil change intervals. Control arm rubber bushings are a known weak spot on the RS front axle.
- !! Timing Belt Failure from Exceeded Maintenance Interval from 120,000 km
The K4M uses a timing belt that can break if the change interval (every 5 years or 120,000 km) is exceeded. In the 16V interference engine design a belt failure inevitably causes valve damage and total cylinder head destruction.
Symptoms: Sudden engine stop, no restart possible, compression failure - !! Camshaft Phaser: Cold-Start Rattle from 80,000 km
The camshaft phaser on the K4M wears with excessively long oil change intervals or poor-quality oil. Typical: brief cold-start rattle that disappears once the engine reaches operating temperature. Repair costs around €350–850; combine with timing belt replacement.
Symptoms: Rattling for 3–5 seconds on cold start (especially below 0°C), engine then runs normally; increased consumption if the phaser runs permanently open - !! Timing Belt: Labour-Intensive Change Due to Tight Engine Bay from 120,000 km
The K4M engine in the Twingo RS has limited engine bay clearance, making the timing belt change labour-intensive. Independent garages from €460, Renault dealers up to €1,100. Always replace the water pump at the same time. Interval: 120,000 km or 6 years.
Symptoms: No warning before belt failure — check service history for documented replacement
+ 6 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
A proven 2.0-litre 16-valve with good long-term stability but a few typical age-related issues. Replace the timing belt and cam phaser together when due; the phaser announces itself beforehand with a diesel-like rattle when warm. The belt-driven water pump is part of the mandatory scope. Crankcase ventilation and valve stem seals cause oil consumption with age, rising beyond 150,000 km. On well-kept examples 250,000 to 300,000 km are easily reached.
- !! Timing belt failure — engine damage from 120,000 km
The 2.0 16V is an interference engine. If the timing belt snaps from an overdue interval, all valves bend and in the worst case piston damage follows. On older cars often an economic write-off.
Symptoms: Sudden engine stall without warning, no longer starts, bent valves - !! Water pump in the timing belt drive from 120,000 km
The belt-driven water pump should be replaced together with the belt. If it fails separately, overheating threatens and in the extreme a belt failure with engine damage. Removing it again doubles the labour cost.
Symptoms: Coolant loss, rising temperature gauge, squealing from the timing belt area, acute overheating on failure - !! Oil Consumption from Coked Piston Rings from 150,000 km
Higher-output F4R engines tend to increased oil consumption at high mileages from coked and stuck piston rings. Regular short full-throttle runs help preventively.
Symptoms: Blue smoke under acceleration and on overrun, dropping oil level
+ 6 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
Vehicle Weaknesses
| Weakness | Cost | |
|---|---|---|
| Water ingress damages wiring harness under driver's seat Blocked bodywork drainage channels let water into the interior and damage the wiring harness under the driver's seat. Numerous electrical failures result. Regular inspection of drains recommended. Symptoms: Various electrical failures, damp floor mat, short circuits | Medium | |
| Voltage relay 1155 in A-pillar defective A defective relay 1155 in the left A-pillar disables the power supply of several control units. Power steering, air conditioning, radio, navigation and boot release can all fail simultaneously. Symptoms: Multiple systems fail simultaneously: power steering, air conditioning, radio, interior lighting and navigation. from 80,000 km | Low | |
| Window regulators and lighting defective Rear window regulators fail. Lighting fails regularly within 4 years. Typical electronics problems of the range with moisture as a frequent cause. Symptoms: Window regulator unresponsive, defective lights | Low |
Test Reports
AUTO BILD TÜV-Report
Failed springs and dampers are a recurring weakness. Steering joints are regularly flagged. Front lighting is too often defective; older vehicles show increased brake disc wear.
2024-11Alternatives
Explore more
Known Problems and Issues +
A total of 71 weaknesses have been documented for the Renault Scenic 3 (2009–2016) — 61 engine-related and 10 vehicle-related. 2 problem engines: H5F (1.2L TCe), R9M (1.6L dCi). Typical issues affect Electronics, Suspension, Brakes, Rust.
Scenic (F9Q, 2009–2013) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 125–131 PS.
Scenic (F9Q, 2009–2013) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 120–131 PS.
Scenic (K9K, 2009–2016) — Be Careful: Connecting Rod Bearing Wear, High-Pressure Pump (Delphi) Failure, Timing belt failure — engine destruction. Power: 103–110 PS.
Scenic (M9R, 2009–2016) — Be Careful: Injector Removal Causes Cylinder Head Damage, Coolant Loss / Seal Damage, Timing chain stretch. Power: 150 PS.
Scenic (M9R, 2009–2016) — Be Careful: Injector Removal Causes Cylinder Head Damage, Coolant Loss / Seal Damage, Timing chain stretch. Power: 160 PS.
Scenic (R9M, 2011–2016) — Stay Away!: Timing Chain Stretch, Connecting Rod Failure (Condensation Water), EGR Cooler Crack / Coolant Loss. Power: 131 PS.
Scenic (K4M, 2009–2016) — Be Careful: Timing Belt Failure from Exceeded Maintenance Interval, Camshaft Phaser: Cold-Start Rattle, Timing Belt: Labour-Intensive Change Due to Tight Engine Bay. Power: 105–111 PS.
Scenic (H4J, 2009–2013) — Be Careful: Chain Tensioner: Cold-Start Rattle and Stretch, Cylinder Head Crack: Coolant Loss, Wastegate Wear on the Small Turbo. Power: 131 PS.
Scenic (F4R, 2009–2016) — Be Careful: Timing belt failure — engine damage, Water pump in the timing belt drive, Oil Consumption from Coked Piston Rings. Power: 135–140 PS.
Scenic (H5F, 2013–2016) — Stay Away!: Timing Chain Stretches Prematurely, High Oil Consumption, Turbocharger Failure. Power: 116 PS.
Scenic (H5F, 2013–2016) — Stay Away!: Timing Chain Stretches Prematurely, High Oil Consumption, Turbocharger Failure. Power: 132 PS.
What to watch out for with the Renault Scenic? See the detailed listing of all engine and vehicle weaknesses in the sections above.
Frequently Asked Questions
What problems and weaknesses does the Renault Scenic 3 have? +
What should I look for when buying a used Renault Scenic 3? +
Which engine is recommended? +
Which Renault Scenic 3 engine is the most fun? +
Is the Renault Scenic 3 worth buying used? +
What horsepower variants are available for the Renault Scenic 3? +
Last updated: February 2026 · All information without guarantee