Install Chrome Extension Chrome Extension
Renault · Van · 2003–2009 Custom Search

Renault Scenic 2

Weaknesses, engine ratings and buying advice

3.0 / 5.0 · Based on 5 engine variants · How we rate
Most Fun Engine

135 PS

Scenic · Benzin

Capable Van

Decent
Most Reliable Engine

75–98 PS

1.4L 16V Benzin

4 weaknesses

Good Choice
Problem Engine

61–116 PS

1.5L dCi Diesel

5 weaknesses

Stay Away!

Generations


Engine Overview

The Renault Scenic 2 is available with 5 engine variants — from 61 to 169 hp.

1.5L dCi · Diesel· 82–110 PS
2003 2009

Renault's most-produced diesel with over 20 years of production history — with exemplary maintenance (oil every 10,000 km, fuel filter every 8,000–10,000 km) over 300,000 km is achievable. Biggest weakness: connecting rod bearings spin from around 100,000–150,000 km, especially with extended oil change intervals. Common-rail injectors (Delphi) and EGR valve are further service items.

  • !! Connecting Rod Bearing Wear from 130,000 km

    The K9K connecting rod bearings are design-sensitive. With overly long oil change intervals or incorrect oil the bearing shells spin from around 100,000–150,000 km, resulting in total engine failure.

    Symptoms: Knocking engine noise, oil pressure warning light, sudden engine stop
    2,000–5,000 $
  • !! High-Pressure Pump (Delphi) Failure from 90,000 km

    The Delphi high-pressure pump shows weaknesses from around 80,000 km. Metal wear from the pump contaminates the fuel circuit and damages the injectors and common rail — with consequential damage included.

    Symptoms: Starting difficulties, sudden engine stall, 'injection fault' message
    1,100–5,000 $
  • !! Injectors Sensitive to Fuel Quality from 120,000 km

    K9K injectors are very sensitive to fuel quality. Poor-quality diesel or clogged fuel filters lead to rough running, increased consumption and expensive injector replacement.

    Symptoms: Engine hesitation, power loss, increased fuel consumption, black smoke
    300–1,200 $

+ 2 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.9L dCi · Diesel· 110–131 PS
2003 2009

Solid early-generation dCi with a Bosch common-rail system that holds up well. Turbo failures and con-rod bearing damage are the known risks. The oil pump wears with mileage — 10,000 km oil changes are non-negotiable. Timing belt every 90,000-120,000 km.

  • !! Turbocharger Failure from 140,000 km

    The turbocharger on the F9Q is a known weak spot. Shaft play, oil supply problems and heat damage cause power loss and limp mode, typically from 120,000–160,000 km.

    Symptoms: Whistling from turbo, power loss, blue/white smoke clouds, limp mode
    600–1,800 $
  • !! Injector Failure from 120,000 km

    The common-rail injectors on the F9Q are prone to contamination and mechanical wear. Loose injectors or faulty injection leads to misfires and the fault code 'injection defective'.

    Symptoms: Engine stumbling, misfires, difficult cold start, 'injection defective' message
    400–1,500 $
  • !! EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits from 100,000 km

    The EGR valve and intercooler on the F9Q are prone to heavy sooting. A burst intercooler manifests as power loss and heavy smoke — a well-known problem on early Laguna II models.

    Symptoms: Heavy smoke, significant power loss, rough engine running
    200–700 $

+ 2 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.4L 16V · Petrol· 98 PS
2003 2009

Compact 1.4-litre 16-valve with solid fundamental construction; timing belt bends valves on failure, so replacement no later than every 60,000 km. Engine runs without notable weaknesses with correct care; camshaft adjuster should be inspected at the timing belt change.

  • !! Timing Belt Failure with Valve Damage from 120,000 km

    The K4J 1.4 16V is an interference engine; if the timing belt breaks, the valves bend. The risk increases significantly after long intervals or with aged tensioners. Change interval: no later than every 5 years / 120,000 km.

    Symptoms: Sudden engine stop, no restart, compression loss in multiple cylinders
    350–2,500 $
  • ! Ignition Coil Failure from 80,000 km

    The Renault-typical Sagem ignition coils are also the most common cause of misfires and power loss in the K4J. Affordable aftermarket alternatives are recommended.

    Symptoms: Misfire, cylinder dropout, engine warning light
    40–200 $
  • ! Throttle Body Contamination from 70,000 km

    The electronic throttle body on the K4J is prone to deposits from crankcase ventilation oil mist, causing idle fluctuations and occasional stalling.

    Symptoms: Rough idle, engine stalls, power loss at low revs
    60–250 $

+ 1 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.6L 16V · Petrol· 110–113 PS
2003 2009

The K4M in the Twingo RS — 1.6 litres, 16 valves, 133 hp — is a naturally aspirated engine with an honest character: it needs revs, but rewards every blip above 5,000 rpm with a rev-happy sound that turbocharged cars cannot reproduce. In the 980 kg Twingo RS it feels stronger than the numbers suggest. Timing belt every 120,000 km or 6 years — water pump always at the same time. Camshaft adjuster wears with excessive oil change intervals. Control arm rubber bushings are a known weak spot on the RS front axle.

  • !! Timing Belt Failure from Exceeded Maintenance Interval from 120,000 km

    The K4M uses a timing belt that can break if the change interval (every 5 years or 120,000 km) is exceeded. In the 16V interference engine design a belt failure inevitably causes valve damage and total cylinder head destruction.

    Symptoms: Sudden engine stop, no restart possible, compression failure
    400–2,500 $
  • !! Timing Belt: Labour-Intensive Change Due to Tight Engine Bay from 120,000 km

    The K4M engine in the Twingo RS has limited engine bay clearance, making the timing belt change labour-intensive. Independent garages from €460, Renault dealers up to €1,100. Always replace the water pump at the same time. Interval: 120,000 km or 6 years.

    Symptoms: No warning before belt failure — check service history for documented replacement
    460–1,100 $
  • !! Camshaft Adjuster Failure from 100,000 km

    The variable valve timing (VVT) on the K4M 782 and similar variants is prone to malfunctions. The actuator wears and causes rattling and power loss, particularly on a warm engine between 1,500 and 4,000 rpm.

    Symptoms: Sewing-machine-like rattling on a warm engine, power loss, camshaft control fault code
    200–600 $

+ 5 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

2.0L 16V · Petrol· 135–140 PS
2003 2009

Tried-and-tested 2.0 16-valve with solid long-term track record. Always replace the timing belt and cam adjuster together when due. Oil appetite tends to grow past 150,000 km. Well-looked-after examples regularly crack 250,000-300,000 km without drama.

  • !! Timing Belt Replacement Involved and Costly from 120,000 km

    The F4R also uses a toothed belt valve timing system. The necessary removal of intake manifold and ignition coils makes the change labour-intensive and expensive — often 600–900 € labour alone.

    Symptoms: If belt snaps: sudden engine stop with valve damage
    500–2,500 $
  • !! Oil Consumption from Coked Piston Rings from 150,000 km

    Higher-output F4R engines tend to increased oil consumption at high mileages from coked and stuck piston rings. Regular short full-throttle runs help preventively.

    Symptoms: Blue smoke under acceleration and on overrun, dropping oil level
    800–3,000 $
  • ! Ignition Coils Under Intake Manifold from 80,000 km

    The ignition coils on the F4R 2.0 16V are hidden under the intake manifold. Every coil replacement requires full manifold removal, which drives up repair costs significantly.

    Symptoms: Cylinder dropout, rough running, engine warning light, poor refinement
    200–700 $

+ 1 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

Vehicle Weaknesses

WeaknessCost
Control units damaged by moisture ingress

Blocked water drainage channels lead to water ingress under the driver's seat. This damages the wiring harness and control units. Extensive repairs are the result.

Symptoms: Various electrical failures, damp driver's seat footwell
Medium
!Window regulators and electronics defective

Defective window regulators, boot lid openers, wiper motors and radio systems are classics on the Scenic II. Instrument cluster unit fails; inexpensive repair available. Control units damaged by moisture.

Symptoms: Window regulator unresponsive, radio dead, speedo defective
Low
!Instrument cluster fails

The instrument cluster and speedo can fail completely, frequently due to solder joint defects on the circuit board. Reconditioning by specialists is possible; new parts are expensive and increasingly hard to find.

Symptoms: Speedo, fuel gauge or rev counter showing no values, display dark.
from 120,000 km
Low

Alternatives

Same Segment

Citroën C4 Picasso I

Van (2006–2013)

Same Segment

Ford Galaxy WA6

Van (2006–2015)

Same Segment

Ford S-Max WA6

Van (2006–2015)

Same Segment

Kia Carens UN

Van (2006–2013)

Same Segment

Honda Odyssey RL3

Van (2005–2010)

Same Segment

Mercedes-Benz B-Klasse W245

Van (2005–2012)

Explore more

Known Problems and Issues +

A total of 34 weaknesses have been documented for the Renault Scenic 2 (2003–2009) — 26 engine-related and 8 vehicle-related. One problem engine: K9K (1.5L dCi). Typical issues affect Electronics, Suspension, Other, Brakes. Considered reliable: K4J (1.4L 16V).

Scenic (F9Q, 2003–2009) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 116–125 PS.

Scenic (F9Q, 2003–2009) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 110–120 PS.

Scenic (F9Q, 2003–2009) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 110–116 PS.

Scenic (K9K, 2003–2009) — Stay Away!: Connecting Rod Bearing Wear, High-Pressure Pump (Delphi) Failure, Injectors Sensitive to Fuel Quality. Power: 82–86 PS.

Scenic (K9K, 2003–2009) — Stay Away!: Connecting Rod Bearing Wear, High-Pressure Pump (Delphi) Failure, Injectors Sensitive to Fuel Quality. Power: 101–110 PS.

Scenic (F9Q, 2005–2009) — Be Careful: Turbocharger Failure, Injector Failure, EGR and Intercooler Soot Deposits. Power: 125–131 PS.

Scenic (K4M, 2003–2009) — Be Careful: Timing Belt Failure from Exceeded Maintenance Interval, Timing Belt: Labour-Intensive Change Due to Tight Engine Bay, Camshaft Adjuster Failure. Power: 110–113 PS.

Scenic (F4R, 2003–2009) — Be Careful: Timing Belt Replacement Involved and Costly, Oil Consumption from Coked Piston Rings, Ignition Coils Under Intake Manifold. Power: 135–140 PS.

What to watch out for with the Renault Scenic? See the detailed listing of all engine and vehicle weaknesses in the sections above.

Frequently Asked Questions

What problems and weaknesses does the Renault Scenic 2 have? +
The Renault Scenic 2 has 26 known engine weaknesses and 8 vehicle weaknesses.
What should I look for when buying a used Renault Scenic 2? +
faq.watch_a_avoid faq.watch_a_rec
Which engine is recommended? +
Good choice: K4J (1.4L 16V). The most reliable engine is the K4J (1.4L 16V) with the lowest risk score. The most fun to drive is the F4R (2.0L 16V). Problem engine: K9K (1.5L dCi) — stay away!
Which Renault Scenic 2 engine is the most reliable? +
The {code} ({displacement}) is the most reliable engine in the Renault Scenic 2. It has the lowest risk score of all available engines and is rated "Good Choice". However, there are 4 known weaknesses to be aware of.
Which Renault Scenic 2 engine is the most fun? +
The {code} ({displacement}) offers the most driving fun in the Renault Scenic 2 — rated: "Decent". {description} 2.0 16V with 135 hp — in the Scenic more about comfort than sport. Capable on the motorway.
Is the Renault Scenic 2 worth buying used? +
The Renault Scenic 2 requires careful consideration — choosing the right engine variant is crucial.
What horsepower variants are available for the Renault Scenic 2? +
The Renault Scenic 2 is available with engine variants from 61 to 169 hp. Petrol: K4J (1.4L 16V), K4M (1.6L 16V), F4R (2.0L 16V). Diesel: F9Q (1.9L dCi), K9K (1.5L dCi).

Last updated: February 2026 · All information without guarantee