BMW M5 F90 — Problems & Common Faults
Weaknesses, engine ratings and buying advice
The M5 F90 (2017–2023) is the last purely V8-driven M5 — its successor, the G90, arrives as a plug-in hybrid weighing 2.4 tonnes. The F90, by contrast: 1,855 kg, the S63B44T4 with 600 hp (Competition: 625 hp, CS: 635 hp), free breathing, no power cables. Anyone who wants an M5 that feels like a sports car rather than a technology demonstrator cannot get past the F90.
The S63B44T4 is not a gentle engine — but it is a cultivated berserker. 750 Nm from 1,800 to 5,600 rpm, water-cooled turbocharger bearings (which prevents oil coking when the engine is switched off), a modified charge air cooling concept. At 4,000 rpm a V8 crescendo begins that leaves nobody cold. But: the engine comes from the N63 family, and that family has its quirks. Oil consumption is a family trait — BMW's tolerance is 1 litre/10,000 km, the reality on hard-worked engines can be 0.5–0.8 litres/1,000 km. Check the oil level at every second fuel stop. Connecting rod bearing damage (destroyed crankshaft bearing shell) is the worst case — documented, and usually caused by insufficient warm-up plus early track-day loads. An engine rebuild runs deep into five figures. Prevention: oil temperature above 80 °C first, 10 minutes of idling to cool down after a track day.
High-pressure pump recall (MY 2018–2019) — the pump works loose because of insufficient tightening torques, allowing fuel to escape. Check before buying. The cooling system is marginal under sustained load — water pump and thermostat are wear items from around 80,000 km. The ZF 8HP judders when pulling away cold — a transmission oil change at 80,000–100,000 km is mandatory.
Competition vs. standard vs. CS: the standard car (600 hp) sits 7 mm higher, is softer and the better all-rounder. The Competition (625 hp) takes its setup from the M8 Gran Coupé: firmer, lower, 25 hp more — not noticeable on the road, but it is on bad asphalt. CS (635 hp, 2021): 70 kg lighter (23 kg of that from the carbon-ceramic brakes alone (lighter, more heat-resistant, but extremely expensive to replace)), carbon bonnet/splitter/diffuser/mirrors/seats, Pirelli P Zero Corsa from the factory, yellow daytime running light signature, gold-bronze kidney grille. List price $198,500 (€180,400), barely any depreciation used.
xDrive + M modes: 4WD (all-wheel drive), 4WD Sport (rear-biased, DSC active — the mode for 99% of track days), 2WD (pure rear-wheel drive, DSC completely off — for experts only). The system feels like rear-wheel drive but instantly provides traction at the front when needed. That is the F90's party trick.
LCI 2020: slimmer headlights, larger kidney grille, dampers from the M8 GC (noticeably better), display grown to 12.3", a new track mode arrangement. Prefer post-LCI where possible.
Test drive: at 4,000 rpm the S63 starts to sing — no artificially amplified sound, that is the engine. Full throttle in 4WD Sport: the rear slides out gently, DSC keeps control. On twisty country roads it is astonishingly agile for 1,855 kg — the active M differential pulls it round the corner. No E63, no Panamera manages this balancing act so convincingly.
Market in 2026: pre-LCI standard from $66,000 (€60,000). Competition LCI with under 50,000 km $82,500–110,000 (€75,000–100,000). The CS rarely below $143,000 (€130,000). Early F90s (MY 2018) have massive depreciation behind them (−$77,000, €70,000 over 5,400 km in three years) — buying now means buying at the bottom of the market for a car with no direct successor. Insider pick: post-LCI Competition (autumn 2020 on) — the M8 GC dampers make a real difference. Check the oil change history (7,500–8,000 km instead of the 15,000 km the BMW display suggests). Verify the high-pressure pump recall on MY 2018–2019 cars.
Generations
Engine Overview
The BMW M5 F90 is available with 3 engine variants — from 600 to 635 hp.
The most mature S63 generation: revised bearing geometry, Valvetronic. The sound remains S63-typical — no raw AMG aggression, rather a deep V8 growl with turbo whistle as an accent. Sonically restrained from the factory, which many owners correct with aftermarket exhaust systems. The M xDrive system can be switched to pure rear-wheel drive — in dry 2WD mode the car becomes a thoroughbred drift tool. Electric wastegate actuators are the new weakness of this generation. Oil changes every 8,000 km with quality full synthetic; do not rely on Longlife intervals. The con rod bearing issue is reduced but not eliminated by the revised geometry — oil analysis remains worthwhile.
- !! Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated) from 80,000 km
Revised connecting rod design compared to S63TU with 8 additional oil drillings. Despite this, documented failures exist: a workshop case study shows an F90 M5 with connecting rod and crankshaft damage. The F90 sees the problem less often than the F10.
Symptoms: Noticeable knocking from the engine, metal particles in the sump and filter housing, crankshaft damage as a consequence of delayed diagnosis - !! Thermostat and expansion tank worn from 40,000 km
The S63B44T4 generates extreme heat in the V-valley. Thermostat and plastic expansion tank are prone to premature wear at higher mileages. The overheating risk on failure is considerable.
Symptoms: Coolant loss without visible leak, temperature gauge fluctuates or rises too high, coolant level warning, steam from engine bay. - !! High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure from 120,000 km
The high-pressure fuel pump can fail at high mileages or with aggressive use. Fuel pressure drop causes noticeable power loss and can secondarily damage injectors and turbochargers.
Symptoms: Power loss under high load, hard starting, fault code fuel pressure too low (P0087), stumbling at full throttle.
+ 9 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The most mature S63 generation: revised bearing geometry, Valvetronic. The sound remains S63-typical — no raw AMG aggression, rather a deep V8 growl with turbo whistle as an accent. Sonically restrained from the factory, which many owners correct with aftermarket exhaust systems. The M xDrive system can be switched to pure rear-wheel drive — in dry 2WD mode the car becomes a thoroughbred drift tool. Electric wastegate actuators are the new weakness of this generation. Oil changes every 8,000 km with quality full synthetic; do not rely on Longlife intervals. The con rod bearing issue is reduced but not eliminated by the revised geometry — oil analysis remains worthwhile.
- !! Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated) from 80,000 km
Revised connecting rod design compared to S63TU with 8 additional oil drillings. Despite this, documented failures exist: a workshop case study shows an F90 M5 with connecting rod and crankshaft damage. The F90 sees the problem less often than the F10.
Symptoms: Noticeable knocking from the engine, metal particles in the sump and filter housing, crankshaft damage as a consequence of delayed diagnosis - !! Thermostat and expansion tank worn from 40,000 km
The S63B44T4 generates extreme heat in the V-valley. Thermostat and plastic expansion tank are prone to premature wear at higher mileages. The overheating risk on failure is considerable.
Symptoms: Coolant loss without visible leak, temperature gauge fluctuates or rises too high, coolant level warning, steam from engine bay. - !! High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure from 120,000 km
The high-pressure fuel pump can fail at high mileages or with aggressive use. Fuel pressure drop causes noticeable power loss and can secondarily damage injectors and turbochargers.
Symptoms: Power loss under high load, hard starting, fault code fuel pressure too low (P0087), stumbling at full throttle.
+ 9 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The most mature S63 generation: revised bearing geometry, Valvetronic. The sound remains S63-typical — no raw AMG aggression, rather a deep V8 growl with turbo whistle as an accent. Sonically restrained from the factory, which many owners correct with aftermarket exhaust systems. The M xDrive system can be switched to pure rear-wheel drive — in dry 2WD mode the car becomes a thoroughbred drift tool. Electric wastegate actuators are the new weakness of this generation. Oil changes every 8,000 km with quality full synthetic; do not rely on Longlife intervals. The con rod bearing issue is reduced but not eliminated by the revised geometry — oil analysis remains worthwhile.
- !! Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated) from 80,000 km
Revised connecting rod design compared to S63TU with 8 additional oil drillings. Despite this, documented failures exist: a workshop case study shows an F90 M5 with connecting rod and crankshaft damage. The F90 sees the problem less often than the F10.
Symptoms: Noticeable knocking from the engine, metal particles in the sump and filter housing, crankshaft damage as a consequence of delayed diagnosis - !! Thermostat and expansion tank worn from 40,000 km
The S63B44T4 generates extreme heat in the V-valley. Thermostat and plastic expansion tank are prone to premature wear at higher mileages. The overheating risk on failure is considerable.
Symptoms: Coolant loss without visible leak, temperature gauge fluctuates or rises too high, coolant level warning, steam from engine bay. - !! High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure from 120,000 km
The high-pressure fuel pump can fail at high mileages or with aggressive use. Fuel pressure drop causes noticeable power loss and can secondarily damage injectors and turbochargers.
Symptoms: Power loss under high load, hard starting, fault code fuel pressure too low (P0087), stumbling at full throttle.
+ 9 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
Vehicle Weaknesses
| Weakness | Cost | |
|---|---|---|
| Front subframe bolts loose — front clunking Loose bolts on the front subframe cause clacking from the front axle. Retorquing the subframe bolts resolves the problem. Symptoms: Hollow clacking from the front axle over transverse grooves and during compression/rebound. from 30,000 km | Low | |
| Adaptive M shock absorbers — oil leakage and fault condition Adaptive dampers can lose oil or generate faults through wiring defects. System then locks into the hardest setting. Increased wear with track day use. Symptoms: Permanently very hard ride, chassis control restricted fault message, no mode change possible. from 80,000 km | High |
Top Reported Issues
Alternatives
Genesis G80 RG3
Full-Size (2021–2025)
Mercedes-Benz EQS V297
Full-Size (2021–2026)
Tesla Model S Palladium
Full-Size (2021–2026)
Mercedes-Benz S-Klasse W223
Full-Size (2020–2025)
Audi RS6 C8
Full-Size (2019–2024)
Audi RS7 C8
Full-Size (2019–2024)
Explore more
Known Problems and Issues +
A total of 18 weaknesses have been documented for the BMW M5 F90 (2017–2023) — 12 engine-related and 6 vehicle-related. Typical issues affect Suspension, Gearbox, Brakes, Electronics.
M5 (S63B44T4, 2017–2023) — Be Careful: Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated), Thermostat and expansion tank worn, High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure. Power: 600 PS.
M5 (S63B44T4, 2018–2023) — Be Careful: Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated), Thermostat and expansion tank worn, High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure. Power: 625 PS.
M5 (S63B44T4, 2021–2023) — Be Careful: Connecting rod bearing wear (mitigated), Thermostat and expansion tank worn, High-pressure fuel pump (HPFP) failure. Power: 635 PS.
What to watch out for with the BMW M5? See the detailed listing of all engine and vehicle weaknesses in the sections above.
Frequently Asked Questions
What problems and weaknesses does the BMW M5 F90 have? +
What should I look for when buying a used BMW M5 F90? +
Which engine is recommended? +
Which BMW M5 F90 engine is the most fun? +
Is the BMW M5 F90 worth buying used? +
What horsepower variants are available for the BMW M5 F90? +
Last updated: February 2026 · All information without guarantee