Install Chrome Extension Chrome Extension
Smart · Supermini · 2004–2006 Custom Search

Smart ForFour 454 — Problems & Common Faults

Weaknesses, engine ratings and buying advice

★★★★★
4.5 / 5.0 · Based on 4 engine variants · How we rate
Everyday hassle beyond the engine: medium from 10 vehicle weaknesses (electrics, body, interior, suspension)

The smart ForFour 454 (2004–2006) is the odd one out in early smart history: a four-door compact, closely related to the Mitsubishi Colt and built in the shared plant in the Netherlands (NedCar). With it, smart left its uncompromising two-seater concept – the ForFour is more conventional, larger (3.75 m) and more family-friendly, but lost the brand's compact unique selling point. It is powered by Mitsubishi petrol engines: 1.1 (3A91), 1.3 and 1.5 (4A90/4A91) with 55 to 80 kW, plus the 1.5 CDI diesel. Unlike the ForTwo, a conventional manual gearbox was available here alongside the automated one, which avoids the notorious jerk. The mechanicals are considered solid and typically Mitsubishi-durable; weak points are mostly age-related: rust on the wheel arches and sills, worn suspension bushes, timing-chain issues on the smaller engines and the usual electrical niggles. Because of commercial failure and a short production run, few were sold, so it is rare on the market today – but it fortunately shares parts with the widespread Colt. The automated gearbox (softtouch/softip) shows the same weaknesses here as in the ForTwo; the manual variants are more relaxed in daily use and usually the better choice. The 1.5 CDI diesel is economical but needs well-maintained injectors and an intact EGR system. Market status 2026: cheap (roughly 1,500–4,000 euros) but hard to find, especially in good condition – the low numbers make a targeted search a test of patience. One advantage: mechanical parts are readily and cheaply available via the Mitsubishi Colt, only smart-specific body and interior parts can be scarce. For buyers wanting a small, economical four-door with smart looks and Mitsubishi reliability, it is an underrated choice – watch for rust, a well-kept suspension and full history. As a practical, affordable city and short-trip car with four seats, it offers good value for money.

Most Fun Engine

177 PS

ForFour · Benzin

Pocket rocket with four seats

Legendary!
Most Reliable Engine

68–95 PS

1.5L CDI Turbo Diesel

1 weaknesses

Good Choice

Generations


Engine Overview

The Smart ForFour 454 is available with 6 engine variants — from 64 to 177 hp.

1.5L CDI Turbo · Diesel· 68 PS
2004 2006

The Mitsubishi-based three-cylinder diesel is tuned for low consumption and delivers usable torque for its size, but stays acoustically rough and gritty. As a compression-ignition unit it needs long periods at operating temperature and suffers under predominantly short-trip use: the diesel particulate filter clogs because regeneration fails to occur, and the injectors tend towards uneven metering with power loss and rough running. Before buying, read out the DPF soot load, check injector return quantities and mind the history. An example run mostly on long distances with good maintenance is economical and durable.

  • ! EGR valve coking on short trips

    On engines driven mostly on short trips, the EGR valve of the three-cylinder diesel clogs with deposits. Exhaust gas recirculation then stops working reliably, causing noticeable power loss. Cleaning often helps only temporarily.

    Symptoms: Noticeable power loss especially under acceleration, sometimes a warning light and exhaust fault code; the problem often returns some time after cleaning.
    90–520 $
1.5L CDI Turbo · Diesel· 95 PS
2004 2006

The Mitsubishi-based three-cylinder diesel is tuned for low consumption and delivers usable torque for its size, but stays acoustically rough and gritty. As a compression-ignition unit it needs long periods at operating temperature and suffers under predominantly short-trip use: the diesel particulate filter clogs because regeneration fails to occur, and the injectors tend towards uneven metering with power loss and rough running. Before buying, read out the DPF soot load, check injector return quantities and mind the history. An example run mostly on long distances with good maintenance is economical and durable.

  • ! EGR valve coking on short trips

    On engines driven mostly on short trips, the EGR valve of the three-cylinder diesel clogs with deposits. Exhaust gas recirculation then stops working reliably, causing noticeable power loss. Cleaning often helps only temporarily.

    Symptoms: Noticeable power loss especially under acceleration, sometimes a warning light and exhaust fault code; the problem often returns some time after cleaning.
    90–520 $
1.1L · Petrol· 64 PS
2004 2006

A solid Mitsubishi three-cylinder using a timing chain rather than a belt, which keeps maintenance costs low. Its output is entirely adequate for the light small car in town and country driving, though it naturally lacks reserves on the motorway. The engine is regarded as durable and undemanding, with no known critical design flaws. Typical age-related items are hardened engine mounts, a leaking valve-cover gasket and sluggish oxygen sensors. Before buying, check for a steady idle and complete service history, then the unit runs trouble-free well beyond 200,000 kilometres.

  • !! Timing chain stretched from 120,000 km

    The timing chain of the 3A91 can stretch, especially when oil changes are neglected. One case is documented at just 53,000 km. Repair costs approx. €1,400.

    Symptoms: Metallic rattling on cold start, engine running rough as if on two cylinders, engine warning light, engine cutting out while driving
    600–1,500 $
  • !! Valve clearance drifts out of spec from 100,000 km

    The 3A91 Mitsubishi engine requires a valve clearance check at 100,000 km and adjustment if necessary. If this is missed, engine running deteriorates and fuel consumption rises.

    Symptoms: Ticking noises from the valvetrain, rough idle, increased fuel consumption, poorer throttle response
    200–500 $
  • !! Clutch actuator and premature clutch wear from 100,000 km

    The automated transmission of the 451 wears the clutch significantly faster than a manual gearbox. By 100,000 km the second clutch is often due.

    Symptoms: Jerking when pulling away, delayed clutch engagement, shifting problems, MHD function unreliable
    500–1,200 $

+ 1 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.1L · Petrol· 75 PS
2004 2006

A solid Mitsubishi three-cylinder using a timing chain rather than a belt, which keeps maintenance costs low. Its output is entirely adequate for the light small car in town and country driving, though it naturally lacks reserves on the motorway. The engine is regarded as durable and undemanding, with no known critical design flaws. Typical age-related items are hardened engine mounts, a leaking valve-cover gasket and sluggish oxygen sensors. Before buying, check for a steady idle and complete service history, then the unit runs trouble-free well beyond 200,000 kilometres.

  • !! Timing chain stretched from 120,000 km

    The timing chain of the 3A91 can stretch, especially when oil changes are neglected. One case is documented at just 53,000 km. Repair costs approx. €1,400.

    Symptoms: Metallic rattling on cold start, engine running rough as if on two cylinders, engine warning light, engine cutting out while driving
    600–1,500 $
  • !! Valve clearance drifts out of spec from 100,000 km

    The 3A91 Mitsubishi engine requires a valve clearance check at 100,000 km and adjustment if necessary. If this is missed, engine running deteriorates and fuel consumption rises.

    Symptoms: Ticking noises from the valvetrain, rough idle, increased fuel consumption, poorer throttle response
    200–500 $
  • !! Clutch actuator and premature clutch wear from 100,000 km

    The automated transmission of the 451 wears the clutch significantly faster than a manual gearbox. By 100,000 km the second clutch is often due.

    Symptoms: Jerking when pulling away, delayed clutch engagement, shifting problems, MHD function unreliable
    500–1,200 $

+ 1 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.3L · Petrol· 95 PS
2004 2006

The Mitsubishi four-cylinder is considered the most mature and balanced drivetrain option in its series. It runs smoother than the three-cylinders, offers noticeably more pull and still keeps consumption in check. The timing chain is designed for low maintenance and no serious weaknesses are documented. Over the years the usual age points appear: engine mounts, thermostat, spark plugs and occasionally leaking camshaft adjusters. Anyone who finds a well-kept example with a clean service history gets a lastingly reliable and cheap-to-run drivetrain.

  • !! Timing chain stretches with neglected oil changes from 95,000 km

    The timing chain of the three-cylinder can rattle from 80,000 km with poor oil maintenance. One documented case shows rattling at 95,000 km after 50–60 k km on the same oil. Rare with regular servicing.

    Symptoms: Rattling on cold start, metallic clattering from the engine bay, engine warning light with advanced wear
    500–1,200 $
  • ! Sump gasket leaking — bonded sheet-metal sump from 50,000 km

    The sump is made of thin sheet metal and only sealed with sealant compound. From around 40,000 km the seal can start leaking. Oil collects underneath and drips when parked.

    Symptoms: Oil patches under the vehicle, oil-coated sump, oil film on the exhaust, dropping oil level
    150–400 $
  • ! Plastic oil filter cap cracks from 40,000 km

    The threaded oil filter cap is made of plastic and can develop hairline cracks if over-torqued. Massive oil loss, including oil smeared across the exhaust and rear bumper on the motorway.

    Symptoms: Severe oil loss, oil film on exhaust and rear bumper, oil smell, rapidly dropping oil level
    50–200 $

+ 1 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses

1.5L · Petrol· 109 PS
2004 2006

The Mitsubishi 1.5-litre four-cylinder comes as a naturally aspirated unit of around 80 kW and as a turbocharged Brabus version of up to 130 kW. The NA variant is uncomplicated, smooth-running and durable, while the turbo version delivers considerably more temperament but stresses the clutch, driveshafts and entire drivetrain noticeably harder. Watch the timing chain and intact engine mounts, and on the turbo also boost pressure and turbocharger condition. A well-kept NA is the stress-free choice, while the Brabus variant demands regular clutch and oil checks.

  • !! Twinamic dual clutch wears — harsh shifting and judder from 80,000 km

    The 6-speed dual-clutch gearbox (Twinamic) shifts harshly and judders on engagement. Crawling in 2nd gear is particularly hard on the clutch as it slips continuously.

    Symptoms: Harsh shifting, juddering on pull-away, vibrations at low speeds, clutch smell in stop-and-go traffic
    800–1,800 $
  • ! Sump gasket leaking — bonded sheet-metal sump from 50,000 km

    Identical to the naturally aspirated version: the thin sheet-metal sump is only bonded with sealant. From 40–60 k km the seal leaks. The sump must be replaced during repair.

    Symptoms: Oil patches under the vehicle, oil-coated sump, visible oil film on the sump underside
    150–400 $
1.5L · Petrol· 177 PS
2005 2006

The Mitsubishi 1.5-litre four-cylinder comes as a naturally aspirated unit of around 80 kW and as a turbocharged Brabus version of up to 130 kW. The NA variant is uncomplicated, smooth-running and durable, while the turbo version delivers considerably more temperament but stresses the clutch, driveshafts and entire drivetrain noticeably harder. Watch the timing chain and intact engine mounts, and on the turbo also boost pressure and turbocharger condition. A well-kept NA is the stress-free choice, while the Brabus variant demands regular clutch and oil checks.

  • !! Twinamic dual clutch wears — harsh shifting and judder from 80,000 km

    The 6-speed dual-clutch gearbox (Twinamic) shifts harshly and judders on engagement. Crawling in 2nd gear is particularly hard on the clutch as it slips continuously.

    Symptoms: Harsh shifting, juddering on pull-away, vibrations at low speeds, clutch smell in stop-and-go traffic
    800–1,800 $
  • ! Sump gasket leaking — bonded sheet-metal sump from 50,000 km

    Identical to the naturally aspirated version: the thin sheet-metal sump is only bonded with sealant. From 40–60 k km the seal leaks. The sump must be replaced during repair.

    Symptoms: Oil patches under the vehicle, oil-coated sump, visible oil film on the sump underside
    150–400 $

Vehicle Weaknesses

WeaknessCost
!Sills and Wheel Arches Rust

The sills and wheel arch edges of the ForFour 454 are regularly affected by rust on older vehicles, as stone chips and moisture attack quickly. Frequent city use and lack of underbody maintenance accelerate the problem.

Symptoms: Rust bubbles on sills and wheel arch edges, visible rust-through, paint flaking
from 90,000 km
Medium
●Exhaust System Corrodes

The ForFour 454 exhaust system rusts primarily at the rear silencer due to typical short-trip city use. Condensation water collects in the silencer and corrodes the steel from the inside. A complete replacement can be due before 80,000 km.

Symptoms: Visible rust on the rear silencer, holes in the silencer, increased noise, rattling
from 70,000 km
Low

Test Reports

Average

The first Smart ForFour 454 is overall unremarkable according to ADAC — as the sister model of the Mitsubishi Colt it shares its solid basic construction. In the breakdown statistics only the battery stands out as a notable weak point.

2021-06

Alternatives

Successor

Smart ForFour 453

Nachfolger (2014–2022)

Same Segment

Mitsubishi Colt Z30

Supermini (2004–2012)

Same Segment

Renault Modus I

Supermini (2004–2012)

Same Segment

Citroën C2 I

Supermini (2003–2010)

Same Segment

Citroën C3 Pluriel I

Supermini (2003–2010)

Same Segment

Fiat Panda 169

Supermini (2003–2012)

Same Segment

Lancia Ypsilon 843

Supermini (2003–2011)

Explore more

Known Problems and Issues +

A total of 21 weaknesses have been documented for the Smart ForFour 454 (2004–2006) — 11 engine-related and 10 vehicle-related. Typical issues affect Rust, Suspension, Electronics, Steering. Considered reliable: 4A90 (1.3L), 4A91 (1.5L), OM639 (1.5L CDI Turbo).

ForFour (3A91, 2004–2006) — Be Careful: Timing chain stretched, Valve clearance drifts out of spec, Clutch actuator and premature clutch wear. Power: 64 PS.

ForFour (3A91, 2004–2006) — Be Careful: Timing chain stretched, Valve clearance drifts out of spec, Clutch actuator and premature clutch wear. Power: 75 PS.

What to watch out for with the Smart ForFour? See the detailed listing of all engine and vehicle weaknesses in the sections above.

Frequently Asked Questions

What problems and weaknesses does the Smart ForFour 454 have? +
The Smart ForFour 454 has 11 known engine weaknesses and 10 vehicle weaknesses.
What should I look for when buying a used Smart ForFour 454? +
faq.watch_a_solid
Which engine is recommended? +
Good choice: 4A90 (1.3L), 4A91 (1.5L), OM639 (1.5L CDI Turbo). The most reliable engine is the OM639 (1.5L CDI Turbo) with the lowest risk score. The most fun to drive is the 4A91 (1.5L).
Which Smart ForFour 454 engine is the most reliable? +
The {code} ({displacement}) is the most reliable engine in the Smart ForFour 454. It has the lowest risk score of all available engines and is rated "Good Choice". However, there are 1 known weaknesses to be aware of.
Which Smart ForFour 454 engine is the most fun? +
The {code} ({displacement}) offers the most driving fun in the Smart ForFour 454 — rated: "Legendary!". {description} 177 hp Brabus turbo, 0–100 in 6.9 seconds, 221 km/h top speed. A four-seat city car with genuine sports car performance — the most surprising fun car of the generation.
Is the Smart ForFour 454 worth buying used? +
The Smart ForFour 454 is a good choice as a used car — 3 of 4 engine variants are rated 'Good Choice'.
What horsepower variants are available for the Smart ForFour 454? +
The Smart ForFour 454 is available with engine variants from 64 to 177 hp. Petrol: 3A91 (1.1L), 4A90 (1.3L), 4A91 (1.5L). Diesel: OM639 (1.5L CDI Turbo).

Last updated: February 2026 · All information without guarantee