MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 — Problems & Common Faults
Weaknesses, engine ratings and buying advice
The third BMW-era MINI Convertible arrived in March 2016 and ran until February 2024, built exclusively at VDL Nedcar in Born, Netherlands. It was the first fully electric MINI roof: 18 seconds, at up to 30 km/h on the move, the front half sliding back 40 centimetres as a sunroof, Union Jack fabric for 600 euros extra. Thicker cloth and quieter than its predecessors, stiffened with torsion struts and a shear panel, yet some shiver over bumps remains, rear visibility with the roof up is close to zero, and the boot takes 160 litres open and 215 closed. A thoroughly unreasonable second car for singles and couples, as the testers put it, and that is exactly how it gets bought.
Engines and versions: One with 102 hp, a 1.2 until late 2017 and a 1.5 until 2022 after. Cooper with 136 hp across the whole run, the more coherent car for most people and cheaper to insure. Cooper S with 192 hp until November 2020, then 178 hp because of the particulate filter, the engine that suits this body. JCW with 231 hp, limited-slip diff and Brembo, from 33,500 euros in 2016, a harder sell open because the body flex absorbs part of the extra power. Cooper D with 116 hp and Cooper SD with 170 hp ran until June 2019. Gearboxes: Aisin six-speed torque converter until 2018, then a seven-speed dual-clutch, the SD with the automatic as standard.
What breaks: First the roof mechanism. The front sunroof section jams or opens on one side, the front latch at the screen frame will not lock, plus Hall sensors, dry solder joints and corrosion in the roof control module. Specialists quote an average of 495 to 595 pounds per repair, and a franchised dealer quoted about 7,000 euros for a mechanism replacement. Second, water: the drains at the A- and C-pillars clog, especially on cars parked under trees, and the water lands in the footwell or the control module; the seals at the screen frame shrink, with draughts and a sliver of light as the signs; the spare wheel well also gets wet via the boot lid seal or tail light. Third the engines, as on the three-door: oil filter housing leaking, engine mounts clunking for about 500 pounds, on the Cooper S the turbo seal after around 100,000 km at 1,600 to 2,200 euros. The rear window can separate from the fabric and the heating element fail. In one survey the convertible sits third in its class at 97 percent.
Test drive: Open and close the roof fully at least twice, plus the sunroof section alone; any hesitation at the latch and any "roof not secure" message is a cost item, and "it just needs a reset" is a fault. Watering-can test over roof and screen frame, then feel the carpets and the spare wheel well. Creaking from the A-pillar or rear points to twist or an accident. A clunky cold start is engine mounts, blue smoke on the Cooper S is the turbo seal. Convertibles are low-mileage summer cars: read the service book, not the odometer.
Market 2026: Cooper S from 2016 to 2018 with 83,000 to 158,000 km at 8,500 to 15,900 euros, Cooper S with 178 hp from 2023 around 28,700 to 35,000 euros. In the UK most listings sit between 10,000 and 20,000 pounds.
The buy: a Cooper or Cooper S with a roof that runs without hesitation, a dry footwell and a garage or carport at home. Then it is the most rounded of the three MINI convertibles.
231 PS
MINI John Cooper Works · Benzin
JCW Convertible 231 hp manual: go-kart pose, rock-hard cornering, 6.6 seconds
Fun to Drive!Engine Overview
The MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 is available with 7 engine variants — from 102 to 231 hp. 1 variants had engine changes — the model year is crucial.
The 1.5-litre three-cylinder diesel was notable in early production for EGR valve clogging — a recall resolved the issue. After the 2018 facelift, the B37 is considered significantly more reliable. Check the EGR valve and intake manifold for soot deposits at higher mileages; monitor particulate filter condition with frequent city driving.
- !! Recall EGR Cooler Fire Risk
BMW recalled 145,000 diesel vehicles (incl. MINI Cooper D/One D) due to fire risk from a leaking EGR cooler. Coolant can contact hot components. Recall should have been carried out free of charge at the dealer.
Symptoms: No direct symptom before fire breaks out; occasional coolant loss may be noticeable - !! Timing Chain Rear-Mounted — High Repair Cost from 160,000 km
The B37's three-piece timing chain is mounted on the transmission side of the engine. Replacement requires complete engine removal — around 16 hours of labour. Total cost can reach €4,000–5,000.
Symptoms: Rattling on cold start, chain noise, timing chain fault codes in memory - !! Swirl flap disintegration — engine damage risk from 130,000 km
Plastic swirl flaps can degrade and disintegrate into the engine. Often discovered after EGR recall.
Symptoms: Sudden power loss, metallic noise, limp mode
+ 3 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The 2.0-litre four-cylinder diesel shows EGR valve problems in early production (jamming, intake manifold overheating), which led to a recall. The intake tract and cylinder head ports can become fouled with soot deposits. Verify recall completion before purchase; inspect the EGR system and intake for deposits.
- !! Recall EGR Cooler Fire Risk
BMW recalled up to 800,000 diesel vehicles (incl. MINI Cooper SD) due to fire risk from a leaking EGR cooler. Engines up to model year 2017 are affected. Recall should have been carried out free of charge at the dealer.
Symptoms: No direct early warning symptom; occasional coolant loss may be noticeable - !! Swirl flap disintegration (B47) from 130,000 km
B47 plastic swirl flaps can also disintegrate. Less common than B37 but documented at high mileage.
Symptoms: Sudden power loss, rattle, limp mode - !! DPF Regeneration Fails in Short-Trip Use from 100,000 km
The B47 in the MINI Cooper D/SD needs sufficiently long journeys for DPF regeneration. Predominantly urban driving prevents complete regeneration and leads to DPF saturation.
Symptoms: DPF warning light, reduced engine power, increased diesel consumption
+ 4 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The 1.5-litre three-cylinder turbo is technically surprisingly mature for its layout: the balance shaft noticeably tames the typical three-cylinder shakes, and from the outside it actually sounds like a proper car. The F56 crowd describes it as pleasantly surprising — eager to rev, 220 Nm from just 1,250 rpm, no nervous burbling at idle. Inside, the sound stays disappointingly muted. The lower engine mount on early production runs tends to transmit vibrations into the steering wheel — check the mount. Keep an eye on the water pump and thermostat from 50,000–70,000 km.
- !! Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production) from 40,000 km
Early B38 engines up to approximately April 2015 had undersized half-shell thrust bearings on the crankshaft. BMW switched to 360° flanged bearings. Primarily affects manual transmission variants.
Symptoms: Vibrations, rough running, in severe cases engine failure - !! Oil Cooler Housing Crack — Oil/Coolant Mixing from 80,000 km
The plastic oil cooler housing can develop cracks leading to oil and coolant mixing. Address immediately — engine damage is likely if left unresolved.
Symptoms: Milky deposits in the coolant expansion tank, oil loss, coolant loss, overheating risk - !! Oil Filter Housing Leaking from 70,000 km
The oil filter housing (incl. oil cooler) tends to leak from moderate mileages onwards. Cause is hardened seals. BMW introduced a production improvement for the oil filter module.
Symptoms: Oil smell, oil spots under the vehicle, dropping oil level
+ 4 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The B48 is the best engine MINI has ever fitted — and it is no longer the most emotional one. BMW reworked this 2.0-litre four-cylinder specifically for the JCW: more boost across the entire rev range, hemispherical pistons and a dedicated turbocharger. In the top version (GP3) it steps up noticeably again. No turbo lag, commanding power delivery — but the acoustic experience is BMW-typically muffled. Technical weaknesses do exist: the plastic coolant vent line at the cylinder head goes brittle from turbo heat and snaps — BMW issued a service action (replacement part 17129845173, rubber hose). The PCV diaphragm in the valve cover can tear and cause oil consumption. Wastegate flutter is typical for the F56 in Green mode. Don't trust BMW's oil change intervals — change no later than every 10,000 km.
- !! Dual-Mass Flywheel and Clutch Premature Wear from 70,000 km
The B48's dual-mass flywheel (DMF) wears out from 60,000 km with spirited driving. Juddering on take-off and rattling noises at idle are early signs.
Symptoms: Juddering on take-off, rattling noises at idle, vibrations at low RPM - !! Coolant Vent Line Breaks — BMW Service Action from 80,000 km
The original plastic coolant vent line between the cylinder head and expansion tank becomes brittle from turbo heat and breaks at the quick-release fitting. Coolant loss can be gradual or sudden. BMW issued service action SI B17 01 21 — replacement with rubber hose (part no. 17129845173) free of charge on affected vehicles.
Symptoms: Sweet maple syrup smell in the cabin, whitish residue at the top of the engine, dropping coolant level without visible puddle, coolant temperature warning - !! Increased Oil Consumption from 80,000 km
The B48 shows increased oil consumption with spirited driving and higher mileages. Up to 0.3 l/1,000 km is considered normal by the manufacturer. With heavier use, piston rings can wear.
Symptoms: Frequent top-ups needed, blue smoke on acceleration, oil level drops quickly
+ 7 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The B48 is the best engine MINI has ever fitted — and it is no longer the most emotional one. BMW reworked this 2.0-litre four-cylinder specifically for the JCW: more boost across the entire rev range, hemispherical pistons and a dedicated turbocharger. In the top version (GP3) it steps up noticeably again. No turbo lag, commanding power delivery — but the acoustic experience is BMW-typically muffled. Technical weaknesses do exist: the plastic coolant vent line at the cylinder head goes brittle from turbo heat and snaps — BMW issued a service action (replacement part 17129845173, rubber hose). The PCV diaphragm in the valve cover can tear and cause oil consumption. Wastegate flutter is typical for the F56 in Green mode. Don't trust BMW's oil change intervals — change no later than every 10,000 km.
- !! Dual-Mass Flywheel and Clutch Premature Wear from 70,000 km
The B48's dual-mass flywheel (DMF) wears out from 60,000 km with spirited driving. Juddering on take-off and rattling noises at idle are early signs.
Symptoms: Juddering on take-off, rattling noises at idle, vibrations at low RPM - !! Coolant Vent Line Breaks — BMW Service Action from 80,000 km
The original plastic coolant vent line between the cylinder head and expansion tank becomes brittle from turbo heat and breaks at the quick-release fitting. Coolant loss can be gradual or sudden. BMW issued service action SI B17 01 21 — replacement with rubber hose (part no. 17129845173) free of charge on affected vehicles.
Symptoms: Sweet maple syrup smell in the cabin, whitish residue at the top of the engine, dropping coolant level without visible puddle, coolant temperature warning - !! Increased Oil Consumption from 80,000 km
The B48 shows increased oil consumption with spirited driving and higher mileages. Up to 0.3 l/1,000 km is considered normal by the manufacturer. With heavier use, piston rings can wear.
Symptoms: Frequent top-ups needed, blue smoke on acceleration, oil level drops quickly
+ 7 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The 1.2-litre three-cylinder turbo with an aluminium closed-deck block shares its architecture with the 1.5: 55 kW with 150 Nm or 75 kW with 180 Nm, direct injection, timing chain. Early production until April 2015 ran half-shell crankshaft thrust bearings that wear under very frequent clutch use; a 360-degree flanged bearing followed, and the retrofit ran as a free technical campaign. Cars from model year 2016 are therefore considered unremarkable, with car-sharing units in constant city duty the exception. Intake valve coking and leaking injectors from around 600 pounds are the care items at high mileage, and the plastic oil filter housing starts to leak.
- !! Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production) from 40,000 km
Early B38 engines up to approximately April 2015 had undersized half-shell thrust bearings on the crankshaft. BMW switched to 360° flanged bearings. Primarily affects manual transmission variants.
Symptoms: Vibrations, rough running, in severe cases engine failure - !! Injectors stick open — oil dilution from 80,000 km
On early B38A12 engines (2014-2016), defective injectors can stick open, dripping fuel into the oil.
Symptoms: Rising oil level, blue smoke on cold start, power loss - !! Oil Filter Housing Leaking from 70,000 km
The oil filter housing (incl. oil cooler) tends to leak from moderate mileages onwards. Cause is hardened seals. BMW introduced a production improvement for the oil filter module.
Symptoms: Oil smell, oil spots under the vehicle, dropping oil level
+ 4 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
The 1.5-litre three-cylinder turbo is technically surprisingly mature for its layout: the balance shaft noticeably tames the typical three-cylinder shakes, and from the outside it actually sounds like a proper car. The F56 crowd describes it as pleasantly surprising — eager to rev, 220 Nm from just 1,250 rpm, no nervous burbling at idle. Inside, the sound stays disappointingly muted. The lower engine mount on early production runs tends to transmit vibrations into the steering wheel — check the mount. Keep an eye on the water pump and thermostat from 50,000–70,000 km.
- !! Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production) from 40,000 km
Early B38 engines up to approximately April 2015 had undersized half-shell thrust bearings on the crankshaft. BMW switched to 360° flanged bearings. Primarily affects manual transmission variants.
Symptoms: Vibrations, rough running, in severe cases engine failure - !! Oil Cooler Housing Crack — Oil/Coolant Mixing from 80,000 km
The plastic oil cooler housing can develop cracks leading to oil and coolant mixing. Address immediately — engine damage is likely if left unresolved.
Symptoms: Milky deposits in the coolant expansion tank, oil loss, coolant loss, overheating risk - !! Oil Filter Housing Leaking from 70,000 km
The oil filter housing (incl. oil cooler) tends to leak from moderate mileages onwards. Cause is hardened seals. BMW introduced a production improvement for the oil filter module.
Symptoms: Oil smell, oil spots under the vehicle, dropping oil level
+ 4 more engine weaknesses + vehicle weaknesses
Vehicle Weaknesses
| Weakness | Cost | |
|---|---|---|
| Moisture in footwell from leaking soft top Water enters the footwell through leaking soft-top seals or A-pillar connections. Problem occurs particularly after car washes or heavy rain. Symptoms: Wet carpet in the footwell after rain. Smell of damp or mould. Water runs along the A-pillar or under the soft top into the cabin. from 40,000 km | High | |
| Electric roof: sunroof section jams, front latch will not lock, roof control module corrodes The fully electric roof is the headache of this generation: the front sunroof section opens on one side or hangs, the front latch at the screen frame will not release or lock, plus Hall sensors, dry solder joints and corrosion in the roof control module. Specialists quote an average of 495 to 595 pounds per repair and 195 pounds for a roof service with drain flushing and latch adjustment; a franchised dealer quoted about 7,000 euros for a mechanism replacement. Symptoms: Roof stops half open, sunroof section runs crooked, "roof not secure" message, windows rise crooked, warning while driving. from 50,000 km | High | |
| Rear window cracks without impact The convertible's rear window can crack without external impact, possibly due to thermal stress when opening the roof. Replacement is costly. Symptoms: Rear window shatters when opening the roof without external impact, or spontaneously during temperature changes. from 50,000 km | Medium | |
| Convertible roof latch error — roof will not open The hood mechanism of the F57 can report latch errors and refuse to open or close. The cause is often dirty micro-switches or corroded contacts. Symptoms: Warning message 'Hood fault', roof cannot be opened or closed, roof stops mid-movement from 70,000 km | Medium | |
| Soft-top seals harden and crack The rubber seals between the soft-top fabric and bodywork harden over time and crack. Wind noise at motorway speeds and water ingress are the consequences. Symptoms: Wind noise from the roof area at higher speeds, water ingress in rain. Seals feel hard and brittle, visible cracks. from 60,000 km | Low | |
| Convertible roof wind noise and rattling The fabric hood of the F57 can develop wind noise and rattling at higher speeds, particularly at the side seals and around the roll bar. Symptoms: Whistling or hissing at motorway speed, hood flapping, rattling noises at the sides | Low |
Test Reports
AUTO BILD TÜV-Report 2026
The F57 Cabrio shows the typical F-series weak points in the lighting. Moisture in the rear lights is a recurring finding. The roof mechanism is more robust than on predecessor models.
2025-11What Car? Reliability Survey 2025
What Car? Reliability Survey 2025 (UK owner survey, cars up to five years old) (electric): reliability rating 94.2%, rank 16 of 29 in the small cars class (class average 95.1%).
2025-10What Car? Reliability Survey 2025
What Car? Reliability Survey 2025 (UK owner survey, cars up to five years old) (electric): reliability rating 94.2%, rank 5 of 19 in the electric cars class (class average 90.1%).
2025-10What Car? Reliability Survey 2025
What Car? Reliability Survey 2025 (UK owner survey, cars up to five years old): reliability rating 99.1%, rank 3 of 29 in the small cars class (class average 95.1%).
2025-10What Car? Reliability Survey 2026
What Car? Reliability Survey 2026 (UK, 39,332 owners, cars up to five years old): reliability rating 99.4%, rank 5 of 225 models overall. Most common reported faults: non-engine electrics (2%), steering (2%).
2026-10Top Reported Issues
Alternatives
Mercedes-Benz SL R232
Convertible/Roadster (2021–2025)
BMW Z4 G29
Convertible/Roadster (2019–2026)
Mercedes-Benz SLC R172
Convertible/Roadster (2016–2020)
Porsche 718 Boxster 982
Convertible/Roadster (2016–2025)
Mazda MX-5 ND
Convertible/Roadster (2015–2026)
Opel Cascada Cascada
Convertible/Roadster (2013–2019)
Explore more
Known Problems and Issues +
A total of 47 weaknesses have been documented for the MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 (2016–2024) — 37 engine-related and 10 vehicle-related. Typical issues affect Body, Electronics, Suspension, Interior.
MINI Cabriolet (B37C15, 2016–2019) — Be Careful: Recall EGR Cooler Fire Risk, Timing Chain Rear-Mounted — High Repair Cost, Swirl flap disintegration — engine damage risk. Power: 116 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B47C20, 2016–2019) — Be Careful: Recall EGR Cooler Fire Risk, Swirl flap disintegration (B47), DPF Regeneration Fails in Short-Trip Use. Power: 170 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B38A12, 2016–2017) — Be Careful: Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production), Injectors stick open — oil dilution, Oil Filter Housing Leaking. Power: 102 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B38B15, 2016–2024) — Be Careful: Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production), Oil Cooler Housing Crack — Oil/Coolant Mixing, Oil Filter Housing Leaking. Power: 136 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B48B20, 2016–2020) — Be Careful: Dual-Mass Flywheel and Clutch Premature Wear, Coolant Vent Line Breaks — BMW Service Action, Increased Oil Consumption. Power: 192 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B48B20, 2016–2024) — Be Careful: Dual-Mass Flywheel and Clutch Premature Wear, Coolant Vent Line Breaks — BMW Service Action, Increased Oil Consumption. Power: 231 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B38B15, 2017–2022) — Be Careful: Crankshaft Thrust Bearing Failure (Early Production), Oil Cooler Housing Crack — Oil/Coolant Mixing, Oil Filter Housing Leaking. Power: 102 PS.
MINI Cabriolet (B48B20, 2020–2024) — Be Careful: Dual-Mass Flywheel and Clutch Premature Wear, Coolant Vent Line Breaks — BMW Service Action, Increased Oil Consumption. Power: 178 PS.
What to watch out for with the MINI MINI Cabriolet? See the detailed listing of all engine and vehicle weaknesses in the sections above.
Frequently Asked Questions
What problems and weaknesses does the MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 have? +
What should I look for when buying a used MINI MINI Cabriolet F57? +
Which engine is recommended? +
Which MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 engine is the most fun? +
Is the MINI MINI Cabriolet F57 worth buying used? +
What horsepower variants are available for the MINI MINI Cabriolet F57? +
Last updated: February 2026 · All information without guarantee